New York Mets

(from Stew Leonard's)

The Muppets

(from Walmart)

Toy Story

(Buzz and Woody from Stop and Shop)
(Rex and Alien from Five Below)
(Toy Story of Terror Cat from Toys R Us)

DC Comics

(from Deal$)

Phineas and Ferb

(Phineas, Ferb and Agent P from Walmart)
(Candace from Stop and Shop)
(Doof from the first visit to the Pez Factory)

Star Wars

(R2D2 from Big Lots)
(everyone else from Deal$)

Halloween

(Witch, Ghost, Dracula and second Pumpkin from Walgreens)
(Bat from first Halloween trick-or-treating)
(Black Cat and first Pumpkin unknown)

Finding Nemo

(from Five Below)

Winnie the Pooh

(from Deal$)

Easter

(from Walgreens)

Marvel

(from Five Below)

Christmas

(from Stop and Shop)

(from Target, obviously)

Classic Disney

(from Deal$)

Rapunzel (Disney Princess)

(from Deal$)

Hello Kitty

(from Big Lots)

McSqueezy the Squirrel / "Open Season"

(Pez of the Day first visit to Pez Factory)

Monsters University

(from Big Lots)

Thomas & friends

(from Toys R Us)

Cars

(from Deal$)

Valentine's Day

(from Five Below)

Wall-E and Eve

(from our first visit to the Pez Factory)

Jake and the Neverland Pirates

(from Stew Leonard's, 2/$3 sale)

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

Bought these when we visited the Pez Factory for the first time.

Squidward / "Spongebob Squarepants"

The only "Spongebob Squarepants" character we own.  (So far)